Early Graphic Novel Review - The Last Dragon by Jane Yolen, Rebecca Guay (4/5 stars)

Reading level: Young Adult/Middle Grade

Genre: Fantasy/Graphic Novel
Size: 144 pages
Publisher: Dark Horse
Release Date: October 4, 2011
ISBN-13: 978-1595827982
Stand Alone or Series: Stand Alone
Source: eGalley from NetGalley.com
Rating: 4/5 stars



I saw the beautiful artwork for this graphic novel at Book Expo of America at Dark Horse's booth there.  Then it was available on netgalley(dot)com for review so I had to download it to read.  The story has a very classic fairy tale feel to it; the artwork is beautiful and flowing.

When Tansy and her father are in the forest Tansy discovers Dragonsbane...which only exists where dragons are.  But there aren't any Dragons left in the world anymore, are there?  When livestock (and people) start disappearing Tansy begins to think otherwise.  Now the town of Meddlesome will need a hero to fight a dragon.  Except maybe a hero alone isn't enough...maybe the hero needs a smart girl like Tansy to help him out.

The artwork throughout is very flowing and beautiful; almost like impressionist painting at points.  While I grew to enjoy the artwork and loved how Tansy, the dragon, and the surroundings were depicted I did have a couple problems with it.  The first is that you can't really tell the facial expressions on any of the characters; the are all very stoic looking.  The second is that the beauty of the artwork lends a very serious and solemn quality to a cute and fun story and, at points in the story, makes the story more serious than I think it is supposed to be.  So, while the artwork is perfect and stunning at times....it is also a bit too serious and formal for the story at times.

The story is very classic fairy tale and I enjoyed it.  The plot is predictable and the writing simple; but that is what this is...a simple folk story.  Yolen does throw some tongue and cheek humor in at places and this adds a bit of fun to the story.

Overall a solid graphic novel.  The artwork is beautiful but doesn't always follow the tone of the story.  The story is a straight-forward fairy tale with a folk tale feel to it and a little humor laced throughout.  Fans of fairy tales and dragons will probably enjoy this book.  It is appropriate for all ages.

This book goes towards the following reading challenges:
- 100+ Reading Challenge
- Fantasy Reading Challenge
- Graphic Novels Challenge List
- E-book Reading Challenge

Briar Rose by Jane Yolan (4/5 stars)

I really like fairy tale retellings, so I was eager to read this book. It is a good book, but not so much about fairy tales as about the Holocaust and one girl's struggle to uncover her grandmother's past.

Becca's grandmother, Gemma, always tells the story of Sleeping Beauty. As Gemma ages and gets sick, the story of Sleeping Beauty is the only thing she ever says. When Gemma passes she leaves a mysterious box of trinkets for Becca. Becca has promised to track down her grandmother's past and uses the box of clippings and trinkets to find out the story of her grandmother who thought she was a Polish Princess.

This was a very well-written book and a very interesting idea. When I realized that this was a book that merged the story of Sleeping Beauty with the Holocaust I was a bit taken aback. I mean the origins of fairy tales are never pretty, but I can't think of an uglier time in human history than the Holocaust. The chapters alternate between short snippets of Gemma reciting her version of Sleeping Beauty and chapters following Becca's journey to find out what happened to Gemma.

More than anything this is a fairly accurate fictional accounting of events that happened during the Holocaust; as you might expect this makes for a somewhat sad, depressing, and distressing read. This story is much more about history, the origins of fairy tales in general, and human nature than it is about Sleeping Beauty. While there are some echoes of hope throughout the book, the majority of it explores the evils of the Holocaust and the struggles people went through during that time. The renditions of some of the actions taken by the Nazis are disturbing and accurate, although not overly gory.

The story itself is very engaging and hard to put down as you are struggling to guess what Becca will find out about her grandmother. All in all it was a good read, just not necessarily a pleasant one. I have read works by Yolen before and her writing style is excellent; I am not used to her dealing with such a serious topic.

Overall, this was an excellent read. People should be prepared more for a different variation of Holocaust events than a retelling of Sleeping Beauty. This book is about so much more than fairy tales. Yolen also has a brief afterward telling which events in the book really happened and which she fabricated to meet the stories needs. For those of you who have read enough about the Holocaust to know how truly disturbing it was; you may want to skip this. I do think that everyone should be exposed to the horrors of those times though so that they are remembered...and this book does an excellent job of doing that while pulling readers through an intriguing story at the same time.

This book goes towards the following reading challenges:
- The Young Adult Reading Challenge
- The 100+ Book Reading Challenge